
New York Governor Eliot Spitzer apparently knocked some heads together and finally convinced seven insurers to cough up $2 billion to settle all remaining property insurance claims over the destruction of the World Trade Center by terrorists on Sept. 11, 2001. It's quite an achievement, and it's terrific for the industry to bring this sad episode to a close once and for all. Read on for my comments, and for full coverage of the settlement details, click here.
At first, the industry was praised for not invoking the war exclusion to deny WTC claims (although I don't think they would have had a leg to stand on had they tried).
However, the good feelings insurers generated with their early support degenerated into a total mess when it became clear that many policies were not completed until after coverage took effect and the worst-case scenario happened on 9/11.
Then the industry tried to limit damages by insisting the attack was one event, not two (even though two separate planes hit two separate buildings at two different times).
Then, many insurers just dug in their heels while lawsuits and negotiations dragged on, prompting organized protests and loads of bad publicity.
Gov. Spitzer's office said that beginning in late March, Insurance Superintendent Eric Dinallo--who was a prosecutor under Mr. Spitzer when he was attorney general, as well as serving more recently as general counsel at Willis--"held dozens of meetings with Silverstein Properties and the insurance companies."
Then, the governor's office said, "this month, when several outstanding issues remained unresolved, Gov. Spitzer became personally engaged in the negotiations."
That's when the head-knocking began. You don't want to mess with Eliot Spitzer.

Comments (1)
I spent 13 months in New York working on damaged elements of the World Financial Center and the Wintergarden for the carriers insuring those properties.
There were so many coverage issues never broached before in circumstances that thankfully remain to this date unique.
It is good to see a resolution to a very complex issue. We are all much wiser now.
Posted by Marc Dubois | May 24, 2007 9:02 PM
Posted on May 24, 2007 21:02